Hogwarts by Chick
The Halls of Undermountain by Tonnichiwa
Beyond Redemption by Diamond
Sword of Shannara by Troedel
Middle Earth by Carnifex
The Goblin Emperor by Xpian
Silo 18 by Larb
Azanulbizar by Deadshade
Numenor by Waldronate
Blood Song by ravells
The Elder Isles (Lyonesse trilogy) by Max
Congrats to Carnifex!! Well done. A lot of great maps. Thanks to everyone for sharing their work with us.
My Battlemaps Gallery http://www.cartographersguild.com/al...p?albumid=3407
Thanks everyone that voted on my map! Quite exciting challage and great entries!
I voted for Revells map because I thought it was a really good one! The other were great as well but had some small things that I did not like (Max's map was great, for example, but was too crowded for my taste).
i wish I wish i could make a hand drawn map again for a competition (I don't think I can since I now have very bad sight - but I guess i could try if I really wanted).
My sites: http://www.facebook.com --- http://www.stormring.com --- http://www.fantasymaps.net --- http://www.megatongames.com --- http://www.darktowershop.com
My finished maps: here
Congrats Carnifex!!
Once I remember how to do it, I'll give your golden compass etc. Sorry been ill for the past couple of days so catching up.
Congratulations Carnifex
Congratulations to Carnifex. As soon as I get back from vacation (Wednesday), your Amazon gift card will be on its way. Just PM me the email address where you'd like it sent.
As for Gudern: I find it ironic that nearly every one of your critiques was subjective. You just don't seem to be able to comprehend that no one is beholden to what your preferred method of mapping is. Even more infuriating are your comments about threads not being 'informative' enough, or not generating Gudern-approved emotions, or being too short (WTF?). I really want to get into a long rant here. I also really want to put you on my ignore list. However, those options would just contribute to the thread being the incorrect length or having unapproved responses or blah blah blah. So instead I'll just end by saying thanks for your time and have a great day.
Congrats on the win Carnifex
I don't recall anyone saying that anyone should be beholden to anyone else's standards or criteria. As far as I know, there are no seriously objective standards for art of any sort. My sense of this discussion is to find out what subjective standards others are employing when they vote, nothing more, nothing less.
He's all but saying that; don't be obtuse. Also, I personally am done talking about this ****. It's ridiculous. In fact, it's descended into sheer farce.
Congratulations on a well deserved win Carnifax!
Cheers,
-Arsheesh
Carnifex has kindly asked that instead of receiving an Amazon gift card, the amount ($20US) go towards the Guild as a monetary contribution instead. So hooray! for Carnifex, and I'll send that 20 bucks Robbie's way as soon as I get home from vacation.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
